I met Matt at Toons at 7:30pm last night, and he'd already downed almost a whole pint of Lite. He said he's usually early—good so far. Actually, though, on the drive down to the bar Wrigleyville, I was questioning why I was even bothering. He's 29, he lives with roommates, he has a goatee—these were the thoughts going through my head. Where's the love?
He was sitting at the bar when I arrived, clad in khakis and a brown plaid, button-down shirt. My immediate thought was "Not my type." His looks did nothing for me—big bushy eyebrows, sticking up like the quills of an alarmed porcupine, were the first thing I noticed (when did eyebrows become such an issue for me?). Plus, he appeared to be chatting up a girl on the stool next to him. He suggested we move to a table but was sure to give her his name before we moved. "Well, that's kind of poor form," I thought, "scamming chicks while waiting for me." As the evening went on, I saw her talking to another guy at the bar, who she also wasn't with. She approached our table as she was leaving, saying, "Matt, I hope it's not presumptuous, but do you have a business card?" "Huh," I thought. "Very interesting." She introduced herself to me as Heather and apologized for interrupting our "date"; while she went to the bar for a pen, Matt assured me it wasn't what I thought. "What do I think?" I asked, laughing. Apparently, she's in sales, and that explains it.
Anyway, back to the superficialities. While his height didn't strike me as overly imposing (I wonder why), his features were overlarge, like on a clay bust from a children’s art class or a Mr. Potato Head, but that included some big, beautiful blue eyes (although his profile says hazel—must have been the wine and smoke). Definitely his best feature.
So, I don't know what to make of him. He likes both sports and arts, he's an actor but has a good day job he loves. He moved here eight months ago from St. Louis with some friends to start a theater company, which has already done three shows but is now on a six-month hiatus to apply for nonprofit status. I've never seen myself with an actor. He didn't come off as vain, but he's definitely very effusive and expressive.
I was a little concerned early on that he was disappointed with me. He came with the mistaken impression that I'm artsy, from my Yahoo job category and my karaoke photo. But I told him how much I enjoyed my arts class in the spring quarter of grad school, and how I wish I had someone to join me for exhibits, plays, etc. I have enough people for sports and bowling already.
He mentioned some book he once read about the soul, and how the soul equals perfection, whereas our personalities are flawed and yadda, yadda, yadda. He seems into spirituality (a fallen away Catholic, with 12 years of Catholic school, which pales to my 19), and that isn't really my cup of tea, yet we more or less agreed about organized religion—i.e., it's more important how you live your life than whether you make it to church every week. He definitely seems more, I don't know, existential than I am, but women want men in touch with their feelings, right? He said he liked my profile because he could tell I don't settle (I immediately thought of Andy), that I take action. It's pretty obvious he's the same way.
I don't think I necessarily would have pegged him as being 29—he didn't seem significantly younger than me or my friends (which probably says more about us than him). There is the whole roommate issue, but maybe that's a temporary arrangement. Still, as I was on my way to meet him, I thought about how I acted at that age, and how I spent hours and hours in bars every weekend (not to mention during the week), and how I would hate to slide back into that lifestyle. I have no problem spending time in bars, but it's not my primary form of entertainment these days. I ended up mentioning that to him, but he's not that type, which is good.
So I don't know. We talked about a lot of stuff—families, histories, jobs, sports (he's a Cardinals fan and doesn't like hockey—bad, good), Mexican food, customer service at restaurants, online dating, how you can't necessarily judge someone from one meeting. I mentioned how I enjoy getting the email exchanges going, within reason, but he pointed out that those can be even more enjoyable when they go on after you've met, leading me to believe I'd be hearing from him today. And he did outright ask me if I'd "do this again," and I said I would, which I wouldn't necessarily have thought in those first 10 minutes or so. He walked me to my car, very gentlemanly, and we hugged good night. (I’ve since read that you shouldn’t let the guy walk you to your car, lest he memorize your license number. And what? Screw with my DMV records? Some of these precautions sound like they come from my mother.)
He definitely has a good personality, a happy personality. He stressed that he doesn't need someone else to make him happy, but he'd like someone with whom he could share his life. He's also willing to take positive steps to make things happen, which is a trait I admire and find in scarce supply. He's taking cello lessons, for God's sake, and wants to enroll in a sculpture class. That kind of thing might worry me if he didn't have a real job, but he's avoiding stagnation, trying new things and meeting new people, and I respect that. So he's not my type, but I do feel somewhat drawn to him. Of course, that could be because I'm fairly certain he'll ask me out again (although I thought that about Ray, too, and my Ray-dar proved qu Playing mind games with myself, I predict that ultimately I won't turn out to be his type. I'm probably too reserved, too much of a stick in the mud, but I admire his "life is for living" attitude, balanced with a sense of responsibility (read: "real job"). It's funny how utterly confident he was, "POSITIVE," to quote him, that I'd like what I saw. He's not a particularly good-looking guy, not in the conventional sense anyway.
When I got home last night, I saw Tim had called. He left a message, and I liked his voice—strong and confident, not like a salesman. I called him back but left a message for him. I'm hoping to talk to him this weekend.
Matt and I have already exchanged several emails today, and, uh oh, he made a reference to dancing. I established immediately that I don't dance, but then he made some comment about how he'd been wondering if I was a good kisser. I didn't reply for a while because I was in the midst of conducting a phone interview for an article I'm working on, and he grew worried he'd offended me. I have to admit that comments like that, especially this soon, tend to make me uncomfortable, but I know I need to lighten up and just be flattered, instead of creeped out. So I replied that I've been told I am a good kisser. He says he's been told the same thing, and that kissing is the key to so many things in his mind, and he enjoys it very, very much. OK, OK—that's enough kissing talk for now.
EH sent me another match. Robert is a 6'1”, 38-year-old general manager from Elmhurst. He sounds pretty good—active, a reader, likes to travel and learn and try new things. Most influential person was his grandfather, who he makes no bones about still missing. Likes chocolate, cheese, wine, and debate. I'll request communication, but I'm kind of down on EH right now (and Elmhurst is a turnoff). All my so-called matches want kids. But you don't know if you don't try.
I also have an email from a Match.com guy. He's a self-described 34-year-old "Indian male" (was the "male" necessary?), studying for his MBA at U. of C. He claims to be smart, funny, etc., "and also like to wear the best clothes." Interesting hobby. He doesn't have a photo, and his profile appears to be hidden.
So, clearly Barry isn't interested (I know, I know—that was clear quite a while ago). His failure to respond puts that one to bed. At this point, I'm more irritated than disappointed. Why did he bother calling me to say he'd like to get together again, and then not follow through at all? I realize lots of reasons can come up, many having nothing to do with me specifically, but once you raise the expectation of another meeting, it’s rather rude not to at least send some weak explanation for why it won't happen. How hard is it to send an email saying you've met someone else, or you're too busy to pursue anything right now? Or you've realized you're gay?
And what's the deal with these jokesters Jeff and Mark in MM, the ones who kept sending one- or two-line emails? I haven't heard from either of them since I stepped up to the plate and explicitly referred to getting together. Why do they bother engaging in these annoying exchanges if they don't truly want to meet? Why go through it (especially in Mark's case, being the poor "typer" that he claims to be)? Do they just get a kick out of stringing women along? Do they chicken out?
Another Yahoo guy contacted me—Michael, or wizenhimer678. "I'm interested, you tall drink of water! Would you like to talk?" He looks like he might be cute, but he lives in a far suburb, has a kid who lives with him part-time, he's conservative, and his profile text focuses solely on what he's looking for: “tall, approachable, fun-loving and easy on the eye…not high maintenance.” What about you, Mike? Wait—his kid lives with him sometimes, but he has roommates? Odd.